Aquaphor vs Vaseline

When you're faced with dry skin, chapped lips, or a minor cut, reaching for a reliable ointment is second nature. Aquaphor and Vaseline are household names in skincare, but have you ever wondered which one is truly best for your needs?

While they might seem interchangeable at first glance, the differences between Aquaphor and Vaseline can significantly affect your skin's healing process. In this ultimate guide, we'll explore their unique properties, discuss their best uses, and help you decide which one should earn a spot in your skincare arsenal.

Ingredients and composition

Vaseline: the pure protector

Vaseline is made up of 100% petroleum jelly (petrolatum). This pure formulation acts as a strong occlusive barrier on the skin, locking in moisture and shielding against external irritants. Its simplicity means fewer ingredients that could potentially cause irritation or allergies.

Aquaphor: the hydrating healer

Aquaphor, on the other hand, contains about 41% petroleum jelly, but it's the additional ingredients that set it apart. It includes:

• Mineral oil: A moisturizing agent that helps the skin retain moisture.
• Ceresin: A wax that adds to the ointment's texture and barrier properties.
• Lanolin alcohol: Derived from wool, it aids in skin moisturization.
• Panthenol (Provitamin B5) – known for its skin-soothing and healing properties.
• Glycerin – a humectant that draws moisture into the skin for deeper hydration.
• Bisabolol – an anti-inflammatory agent derived from chamomile.

These additional ingredients enhance Aquaphor's ability to hydrate and heal the skin, making it a multi-purpose ointment for various skin conditions.

Uses and benefits

Wound healing

Both ointments can aid in wound care, but their effectiveness differs based on the wound's needs.

• Aquaphor: With its humectant properties, it's better for wounds needing moisture and breathability. It's suitable for dry wounds that require enhanced hydration to facilitate healing.
• Vaseline: Its pure petrolatum forms a strong occlusive barrier, making it ideal for protecting wounds from bacteria and irritants. It's especially helpful in keeping wounds moist, which is crucial for proper healing.

Moisturizing

• Aquaphor: Superior for dry skin conditions, eczema, or when your skin needs extra hydration. The combination of humectants and occlusives in Aquaphor helps to attract moisture and seal it into the skin, providing long-lasting hydration.
• Vaseline: Great for preventing moisture loss. Its occlusive properties are effective for normal skin types, locking in existing moisture. However, it might not be the best choice for oily or acne-prone skin due to its thick, greasy texture.

What research says

An insightful comparative study with 76 patients who underwent Mohs surgery (a skin cancer removal procedure) revealed significant differences between the ointments:

• Aquaphor users:
  • 52% incidence of redness at the wound site.
  • 33% experienced redness with swelling.
• Vaseline users:
  • Only 12% incidence of redness.
  • 9% had redness with swelling.
• The no-ointment group:
  • Had higher rates of crusting and scabbing (47%).

Takeaway: Vaseline may be more effective in reducing postoperative wound redness and swelling compared to Aquaphor.

Implication: For post-surgical wound care, Vaseline's simple formulation might minimize the risk of irritation.

How to use Aquaphor and Vaseline effectively

Knowing how to apply these ointments properly can maximize their benefits.

For dry skin and eczema

• Aquaphor: After cleansing, apply a thin layer of Aquaphor to the affected area. For intensive overnight treatment, apply a generous layer before bed and cover with soft clothing to lock in moisture.

For minor cuts and wounds

• Vaseline: Clean the wound with mild soap and water. Pat dry gently. Apply a thin layer of Vaseline to keep the area moist and protected. Cover with a sterile bandage if necessary.

For chapped lips

• Aquaphor: Apply a small amount to the lips as needed throughout the day. Aquaphor's hydrating ingredients can help repair and soothe severely chapped lips.
• Vaseline: Can be used to seal in moisture on the lips, preventing further chapping.

For diaper rash

• Aquaphor: Frequently used in baby care for preventing and treating diaper rash due to its gentle, hydrating formula.
• Vaseline: Provides a protective barrier against moisture, helpful in preventing diaper rash.

For tattoo aftercare

• Aquaphor: Widely recommended for tattoo aftercare because it allows the skin to breathe while keeping it moisturized.
• Vaseline: Generally not recommended for new tattoos because it can block air circulation, potentially hindering the healing process.

Get your personalized vitamin recommendations in less than 3 minutes.

Take the Health Quiz

Choosing between Aquaphor and Vaseline

When deciding between Aquaphor and Vaseline, consider the following factors to determine which is best suited for your needs.

Skin type

• Sensitive skin: Vaseline's simple formula may be better for those with sensitive skin or allergies, as it's less likely to cause irritation.
• Dry or cracked skin: Aquaphor's hydrating ingredients are beneficial for extremely dry skin, as they provide both moisture and protection.

Allergies

• Lanolin sensitivity: If you have a lanolin allergy (common in those allergic to wool), avoid Aquaphor and opt for Vaseline.
• Petroleum sensitivity: Rare, but if you have a sensitivity to petroleum-based products, consider alternative natural ointments.

Desired outcome

• Deep hydration and skin repair: Aquaphor is the better choice due to its humectant ingredients.
• Simple protection and moisture retention: Vaseline excels in creating a protective barrier to lock in moisture.

Postoperative care

• Vaseline may be preferred after surgeries involving the skin, as studies suggest it causes less redness and swelling compared to Aquaphor.

Can you use Aquaphor as a sexual lubricant?

Short answer: It's not recommended.

While Aquaphor is excellent for skin hydration, using it as a personal lubricant isn't advisable for several reasons:

• Compatibility with condoms: Petroleum-based and mineral oils products like Aquaphor can degrade latex condoms, increasing the risk of breakage and compromising protection.
• Potential irritation: Internal use of Aquaphor may cause irritation or infections, as it's not formulated for the delicate mucous membranes.
• Bacterial growth: The occlusive nature of petroleum jelly can trap bacteria, potentially leading to infections.

Recommendation: Always opt for products specifically designed as personal lubricants, which are formulated to be safe for intimate use.

Dos and don'ts of using Aquaphor and Vaseline

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

Here are some of the most frequently asked questions about Aquaphor vs Vaseline.

Final thoughts

Choosing between Aquaphor and Vaseline ultimately depends on your specific skin needs and personal preferences. If you require deep hydration and skin repair, Aquaphor might be your go-to solution with its additional moisturizing ingredients. For simple protection and moisture retention, especially on sensitive skin prone to irritation, Vaseline's pure formula could be the better choice.

Always consider any allergies, especially to lanolin, and consult with a healthcare professional if you're uncertain about which product to use. Remember, the best skincare product is one that suits your skin type and addresses your concerns effectively.

Dr. Dimitar Marinov, MD, RDN, PhD, says, "Both Aquaphor and Vaseline are effective skincare options, but selecting the right one hinges on your specific skin concerns and treatment goals."

Sources and references

• Efficacy and Safety of Topical Dexpanthenol-Containing Spray and Cream in the Recovery of the Skin Integrity Compared with Petroleum Jelly after Dermatologic Aesthetic Procedures
• Postoperative Wound Care After Dermatologic Procedures: A Comparison of 2 Commonly Used Petrolatum-Based Ointments - JDDonline
• Mineral oil lubricants cause rapid deterioration of latex condoms - PubMed